Murder in the Manuscript Room: A 42nd Street Library Mystery by Con Lehane (Minotaur Books, 320 pages, $25.99)
I tend to avoid mysteries for a number of reasons. Let me go over them here:
- Most mysteries tend to feature too many characters. One needs a flow chart to keep track of them.
- Most mysteries have too many quirky characters. Why are these characters stranger than the ones in most novels?
- Most mysteries have too many red herrings.
- Most mysteries go on too long before the mystery in question is solved. And then it happens far too quickly (e.g., 305 pages detailing the story, which is wrapped up at warp speed in the last 10 to 15 pages).
- Most mysteries have too much dialogue and not enough narrative exposition (scene setting and action).
Despite all of this, I found Murder in the Manuscript Room to be quite engaging. Con Lehane offers a unique premise – someone is not only killing in the New York City Public Library, but in the rare manuscripts room. Why? Why there? Why in that room?
I often find myself not caring about the solution to the crime at the center of a mystery novel. However, this time I wanted to know the outcome. What made the read more enjoyable than most mysteries for me is that author Lehane has a bit of a clipped style. He does not overload the reader with facts and details; instead, I found that sometimes he leaves things out. Every now and then, in fact, I wondered if I had skipped a page or two because of his conciseness. (He sometimes, to use a legal phrase, assumes facts that are not in evidence.)
Lehane also throws in a bit of a romance and a variation on the hard-boiled New York City cop. Well done!
Lehane basically has a unique tone as a writer. I like it.
Now I look forward to reading the earlier book in the series, Murder at the 42nd Street Library, and I hope I’m sent a copy of Lehane’s next work.
Me, looking forward to reading a mystery… Imagine that.
A review copy was provided by a publicist. This book was released on November 21, 2017.